This article contains affiliate links. If you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
On July 11, 1881, at four in the morning, thirteen crew members aboard the Royal Navy training ship HMS Bacchante logged a sighting off the coast of Australia: a glowing red light, and inside it, the masts, spars, and sails of a brig standing out in strong relief 200 yards off the port bow. One of the young officers keeping that log was Prince George of Wales, who would later become King George V. The entry read simply: “At 4 a.m. the Flying Dutchman crossed our bows.” It's one of the best-documented sightings of a legend that, by then, had already been circulating among sailors for at least a century.
Verified History and Origins
The earliest known written reference to “the Flying Dutchman” appears in an English travelogue from 1790, John MacDonald's “Travels in Various Parts of Europe, Asia and Africa During a Series of Thirty Years and Upward,” which describes the tale as something sailors already knew well, suggesting the story circulated orally well before that date. The most common account names the ship's captain as Hendrick van der Decken, a Dutch East India Company commander who is said to have defied a violent storm off the Cape of Good Hope, vowing to round the Cape even if it took until Judgment Day, and was cursed to try forever.
Some historians trace a real inspiration to Bernard Fokke, a 17th-century Dutch East India Company captain famous for making the Europe-to-Asia run at what was, for the era, an alarming speed, which reportedly earned him a nickname close to “the Flying Dutchman” during his own lifetime. Whether Fokke's reputation for reckless speed fed directly into the ghost-ship story, or the two simply share an era and a nickname, is something we could not independently verify from a single confirmed source.
The Legend Itself
The Flying Dutchman is described in maritime lore as a ship doomed to sail the seas forever, unable to make port, its appearance considered an omen of disaster for any crew that spots it. Multiple 19th-century accounts describe the ship glowing with an eerie light of its own, visible at a distance even in total darkness, and moving under full sail regardless of the actual wind conditions.
The Bacchante sighting is the most famous royal account, but it wasn't the only widely reported one. In 1939, several eyewitnesses aboard a ship near South Africa, including officers named Davies and Monsarrat, reported watching a schooner of an unfamiliar class sail under full canvas with no wind at all, force their vessel to change course to avoid collision, and then vanish as it entered Table Bay. Third Officer Monsarrat later said the encounter inspired him to write a novel about a phantom ship, and he went on to become a well-known author of maritime fiction.
What's Actually Verifiable
No log entry, photograph, or investigation has ever produced physical evidence of a ghost ship, and the Bacchante account itself carries an unsettling footnote: the sailor who first spotted the light reportedly fell to his death from the topmast not long afterward, a detail that fed the ship's reputation as a bad omen but that we could not verify beyond the crew's own retelling. What is verifiable is the documentary record of the sightings themselves. The Bacchante log was checked by Admiralty officials before Prince George published his account as “The Cruise of H.M.S. Bacchante,” specifically to make sure it contained no factual errors about the voyage, and the 1939 sighting is corroborated by multiple named officers rather than a single anonymous source.
Maritime historians generally treat the legend as originating in real, dangerous sailing conditions around the Cape of Good Hope, a stretch of ocean notorious for storms and shipwrecks, embellished over generations of retelling among crews who had genuine reason to fear it. For a look at how similar undead-at-sea and doomed-vessel traditions appear worldwide, our international legends guide collects other maritime and folk hauntings researchers have never been able to fully resolve.
Cultural Legacy
The legend has outlasted the age of sail by centuries, inspiring Richard Wagner's opera “Der Fliegende Höllander,” Washington Irving's writing, and Frederick Marryat's 1839 Gothic novel “The Phantom Ship.” For readers who want the deeper maritime history rather than the opera version, several nonfiction collections trace the Flying Dutchman alongside other documented ghost-ship cases.
Ghost-Hunting Gear & Further Reading
- “Ghost Ships: Tales of Abandoned, Doomed, and Haunted Vessels” by Angus Konstam — covers the Flying Dutchman alongside the Mary Celeste and other maritime mysteries: search on Amazon
- “The Phantom Ship” by Frederick Marryat — the 1839 Gothic novel that helped popularize the legend internationally: search on Amazon
- “The Cruel Sea” by Nicholas Monsarrat — the maritime novelist whose own 1939 phantom-ship sighting inspired his fiction career: search on Amazon
- A marine-grade compass or brass ship's clock, for anyone drawn to the age-of-sail aesthetic: search on Amazon
As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases.
FAQ
Q1: Did a real king see the Flying Dutchman?
Prince George of Wales, later King George V, logged a sighting aboard HMS Bacchante on July 11, 1881, along with twelve other crew members. The account was checked by Admiralty officials before publication.
Q2: Who was Captain Van der Decken?
The captain most commonly named in the legend, said to have cursed his ship by defying a storm off the Cape of Good Hope and vowing to round it even if it took forever.
Q3: Is there a real historical figure behind the legend?
Some historians point to Bernard Fokke, a 17th-century Dutch East India Company captain known for unusually fast voyages, though a direct link to the ghost-ship story could not be independently confirmed.
Q4: When was the Flying Dutchman first written about?
The earliest confirmed written reference dates to 1790, in a travelogue by Scotsman John MacDonald, though the account implies the story was already well known among sailors before that.
Q5: Was the Flying Dutchman seen more recently than the 1800s?
Yes. Multiple named officers reported a similar sighting near South Africa in 1939, describing a ship sailing under full canvas with no wind before it vanished entering Table Bay.
Comments