This article contains affiliate links. If you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Hunt A Killer is the subscription box that turned “amateur detective” into a legitimate hobby — every month you get a new envelope of evidence, witness statements, and physical clues tied to an ongoing murder investigation. It works, but it isn't for everyone: month-to-month pricing runs about $34.99 plus shipping, you're locked into waiting 30 days between episodes, and eventually you want a format that isn't a subscription at all. Below are eight real, verified murder mystery games — subscription boxes, one-time purchases, board games, and puzzle books — that scratch the same itch without the wait.
1. Deadbolt Mystery Society
Deadbolt is the closest like-for-like competitor to Hunt A Killer: a monthly (or one-time) murder mystery box you solve solo or with up to four people, aimed at ages 13+. Cases are shorter and more self-contained than Hunt A Killer's season-long arcs, making it a better pick if you want a mystery you can finish in one sitting. Check Deadbolt Mystery Society directly for current box availability.
2. Unsolved Case Files
Unsolved Case Files flips the Hunt A Killer format: instead of a monthly serialized story, you buy a single one-time case containing over 50 investigation documents — crime scene photos, coroner's reports, fingerprint cards, and witness statements — and solve it in one 2-6 hour session. No subscription, no waiting.
3. Chronicles of Crime
Chronicles of Crime is a cooperative board game that pairs physical case cards with a companion smartphone app. It's a one-time purchase (base game plus optional expansions), supports 1-4 players including solo play, and each case runs 60-90 minutes.
4. Deception: Murder in Hong Kong
A 4-12 player social deduction game that plays in about 20 minutes. One player is secretly the murderer, another is a mute forensic scientist who can only point at clue tiles, and everyone else has to deduce the truth before time runs out.
5. Murdle: Volume 1
For solo players who liked the puzzle-solving side of Hunt A Killer more than the physical prop-box side, Murdle is a bestselling logic-puzzle book: 100 short murder mysteries solved with a deduction grid, no group required.
6. Escape the Crate
Escape the Crate is a subscription box like Hunt A Killer, but built around escape-room-style puzzle logic rather than pure detective narrative. It ships every two months at $29.99 per crate.
7. Trapped in a Room with a Zombie (Live Escape Room)
A real, long-running in-person escape room franchise with locations across the U.S., running about $28 per ticket. It's not a take-home product, but if what you actually want is the “solve it with friends” social energy, this is worth booking as a one-off night out.
8. Talking Tables Murder Mystery Dinner Party Games
Talking Tables makes themed murder mystery party kits (1920s speakeasy, Orient Express, and similar settings) for groups of roughly 6-8 players, where everyone gets a character sheet, backstory, and secrets to reveal over the course of a hosted dinner.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the cheapest Hunt A Killer alternative?
Murdle is the cheapest by far — a one-time paperback purchase of a few dollars versus Hunt A Killer's $25-35 per monthly episode.
Can you play these solo?
Yes, several are built for solo play: Murdle, Unsolved Case Files, Deadbolt Mystery Society, and Chronicles of Crime all explicitly support 1-player games.
Is there a one-time-purchase alternative that's most like Hunt A Killer's format?
Unsolved Case Files is the closest match — real-feeling case documents, photos, and evidence you physically sort through — but sold as a single case instead of a recurring subscription.
Comments