Best Books About the Bell Witch Haunting

This article contains affiliate links. If you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

The Bell Witch haunting is the only case in American folklore where a spirit is said to have caused a documented death — the family patriarch John Bell died in 1820, and the entity tormenting his family for four years allegedly claimed responsibility. That single detail is why the story has outlived two centuries of retellings, and why the book you pick matters: some sources trace back to the Bell family's own diary, others are historical research, and at least one is a straight novel. Here are the books worth reading, sorted by what each one actually is.

Comparison Table

| Book | Best For | Type |

|—|—|—|

| An Authenticated History of the Famous Bell Witch (M.V. Ingram, 1894) | Readers who want the original primary-source account | Nonfiction, first published record |

| The Bell Witch: The Full Account (Pat Fitzhugh) | Readers who want a modern, footnoted historical deep dive | Nonfiction |

| Our Family Trouble: The Story of the Bell Witch of Tennessee (Richard W. Bell & M. Todd Cathey) | Readers who want the Bell family's own diary-based account | Nonfiction, first-person source material |

| Bell Witch: The Truth Exposed (Chris & Walter Kirby with Camille Moffitt) | Readers who want the perspective of the people who now run Bell Witch Cave | Nonfiction |

| The Bell Witch: An American Haunting (Brent Monahan) | Readers who want the story dramatized as fiction | Novel, basis for the 2005 film |

1. An Authenticated History of the Famous Bell Witch by Martin Van Buren Ingram

Published in 1894, this is the book that put the Bell Witch story into print for the first time and the one nearly every later account draws from. Ingram, a Tennessee newspaper publisher, built it around the diary of Richard Bell — one of John Bell's sons — along with interviews he gathered from people who said they had witnessed events firsthand. It's often nicknamed the “Red Book” by researchers and is still sold in facsimile and reprint editions today.

Search on Amazon

2. The Bell Witch: The Full Account by Pat Fitzhugh

Fitzhugh spent more than two decades researching the case before releasing this 406-page account in 2000, later updated in 2003 and 2012. It reads more like investigative journalism than folklore retelling — footnoted sources, photos of the Bell family's land in Adams, Tennessee, biographical sketches, and discussion notes are all included. It has twice appeared on Tennessee's suggested summer reading list for teens, which says something about how it's regarded locally.

Search on Amazon

3. Our Family Trouble: The Story of the Bell Witch of Tennessee by Richard W. Bell and M. Todd Cathey

This is presented as one of the few accounts to draw directly on records passed down within the Bell family itself, self-published in 2019. It's a shorter, more intimate read than Fitzhugh's or Ingram's — less concerned with cross-referencing outside sources, more focused on what the family reportedly experienced and recorded at the time.

Search on Amazon

4. Bell Witch: The Truth Exposed by Chris and Walter Kirby with Camille Moffitt

The Kirbys own and operate the Bell Witch Cave in Adams, Tennessee, the site most closely associated with the haunting today, and this book is their attempt to separate the parts of the legend they believe hold up from the parts that have been embellished over 200 years of retellings. It's a useful counterweight if you've already read Ingram or Fitzhugh and want a more skeptical, on-the-ground perspective from people who deal with visitors and questions about the case every day.

Search on Amazon

5. The Bell Witch: An American Haunting by Brent Monahan

Monahan's 1997 novel fictionalizes the haunting, naming the entity “Old Kate” and building a narrative arc around Betsy Bell and her family. It's not a historical account — it's a horror novel that uses the real case as its foundation — but it's notable as the direct basis for the 2005 film An American Haunting, starring Sissy Spacek and Donald Sutherland. Readers who want the atmosphere of the legend without the historiography debates tend to start here.

Search on Amazon

If you want the wider context of how the Bell Witch case fits among other documented American hauntings, our full account of the Bell Witch of Tennessee covers the timeline of the haunting itself in more depth.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q1: What is the oldest book about the Bell Witch?

An Authenticated History of the Famous Bell Witch by Martin Van Buren Ingram, published in 1894, is widely credited as the first book-length account, built in part from a Bell family diary and interviews with people connected to the case.

Q2: Is An American Haunting based on a true story?

The 2005 film and Brent Monahan's 1997 novel it's based on both draw on the Bell Witch legend, but both are dramatized fiction — names, timelines, and some events are altered or invented for the story, not a factual reconstruction.

Q3: Which Bell Witch book is the most historically rigorous?

Pat Fitzhugh's The Bell Witch: The Full Account is generally considered the most thoroughly researched modern nonfiction account, with footnoted sources and decades of research behind it.

Q4: Did the Bell Witch really kill John Bell?

According to the legend as recorded in Ingram's 1894 account and repeated in later books, the entity claimed to have poisoned John Bell, who died in 1820 during the haunting — but this claim comes from folklore and family testimony, not an independently verifiable historical record.

Q5: Where can I visit the real Bell Witch location?

The Bell Witch Cave in Adams, Tennessee, near the original Bell family farm, is open to visitors and is run by the Kirby family, who co-authored Bell Witch: The Truth Exposed.

As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases.